The HP Photosmart 7510 uses HP 564 ink in black, cyan, magenta, yellow, and a separate photo black. That extra black is made for photo output, so it should be chosen by its full label rather than treated as the main black cartridge.
Toner Buzz carries genuine HP 564 singles in standard and XL sizes, plus a three-color pack, a four-color XL set, and a standard black two-pack. Choose photo black only for that ink position, or use the pack that matches the group of colors you need.