The OfficeJet R45's two-cartridge packs come in different combinations. HP 45 twin packs contain black ink twice; the HP 45/23 combo pairs black with tri-color. The choice is between keeping a spare black cartridge and ordering both black and color ink together.
Toner Buzz carries genuine HP 45 black and HP 23 tri-color cartridges for the R45. Choose the pack that suits your ink needs, or order either cartridge individually when you don't need a pair.