For the OfficeJet R40xi, HP 23 supplies cyan, magenta, and yellow in one tri-color cartridge. The HP 45/23 combo therefore contains two cartridges, not four separate color cartridges: one for black and one for the three colors. Choose it when you need both cartridge types together.
Toner Buzz carries genuine HP 45 black and HP 23 tri-color singles and the combo pack. For black ink alone, choose a single 45 or the black twin pack, which gives you a second black cartridge to keep ready.