The HP OfficeJet 5510 uses two main ink cartridges: HP 56 for black and HP 57 for tri-color. You only need to focus on the position named by the printer unless black and color are both running low.
Toner Buzz carries genuine HP 56 black and HP 57 tri-color ink as singles, twin packs, and a mixed combo. A single covers one low position, a twin pack keeps an extra of the same cartridge, and the combo covers both.