For the OfficeJet 4110, a twin pack and a black-and-color combo solve different ink needs. The HP 56 twin pack contains two black cartridges; the HP 57 twin pack contains two tri-color cartridges. The 56/57 combo pairs one of each, rather than giving you a spare of the same ink.
Toner Buzz carries genuine HP 56 black and HP 57 tri-color ink as individual cartridges and packs. Choose the combo for both inks together, or a twin pack when you want an extra cartridge of the ink you use most.