The HP LaserJet P3005n uses standard-yield HP 51A or high-yield HP 51X black toner. Buying the Q7551XD dual pack keeps the 51X capacity and adds another cartridge, so it is a quantity choice within that family.
At Toner Buzz, genuine HP 51A and 51X toner comes as individual cartridges, with a 51X two-pack as well. Choose the capacity first; the dual pack makes sense when you want two 51X cartridges in one order.