The HP Envy 5539 uses HP 61 black and tri-color ink. A pack with HP 61XL black adds capacity to black only; its HP 61 color cartridge is standard-yield, unlike a choice to increase both ink capacities.
Toner Buzz carries genuine HP 61 packs for the Envy 5539. Standard black-and-color packs and mixed-capacity packs cover both inks, while the tri-color two-pack is useful for ordering color with a spare of the same cartridge.