Printer Toner vs Ink
It’s a battle that’s raged for centuries...ink vs toner! Who will emerge victorious from the printer/copier wars?
Uh, well, neither really.
Toner and ink are like gasoline and diesel. Both are types of fuel, but they’re used in different engines.
Toner cartridges and ink cartridges are both used to print text and images, but they’re made for different types of machines.
The table below helps break it down:
The Difference Between Toner and Ink
|➜ Used in laser printers||➜ Used in inkjet printers|
|➜ Contains fine powder||➜ Contains liquid ink|
|➜ Higher page yield||➜ Lower page yield|
|➜ Does not dry out or clog||➜ Can dry out and clog|
|➜ Long/unlimited shelf life||➜ Short/limited shelf life|
|➜ Low cost per page||➜ Higher cost per page|
|➜ Higher initial cost||➜ Lower initial cost|
Without getting too complicated, laser printers use a different printing process than inkjet printers.
Inkjet printers, as the name implies, squirt droplets of liquid ink onto paper to form an image. Laser printers etch an image onto a rotating drum which attracts charged particles of dry toner. The rolling drum transfers the image to the paper and the toner is fused to the paper with heat and pressure rollers.
That’s why prints that come out of laser printers are warm.
Let’s break it down this way:
- Laser printers use toner cartridges
- Inkjet printers use ink cartridges
- Toner cartridges contain dry powder
- Ink cartridges contain liquid ink
- Toner cartridges are bigger than ink cartridges
- Toner cartridges typically have page yields ranging from 2,000- 20,000 pages
- Ink cartridges typically have page yields of about 500 pages
- Toner cartridges don’t expire
- Ink cartridges expire
- Toner doesn’t dry out due to infrequent use
- Ink can dry out and clog due to infrequent use
A trio of tiny inkjet cartridges alongside a much larger toner cartridge.
What Is Better? Toner or Ink?
Now that’s a good question! Not “Who will win in a battle between toner vs. ink?” That’s a stupid question!
Let's quickly compare ink and toner based on two (probably most important overall) factors below:
Longevity- How Long Does Toner Last vs Ink?
We believe toner longevity and lower overall print costs make laser printers the way to go.
Ink cartridges carry the risk of malfunctioning if the heads dry out or become clogged. This risk increases the longer that inkjet printers are not used so it is important to use inkjet printers weekly.
In contrast, toner cartridges don't expire and don't get clogged if not used.
Toner vs Ink - Cost
Toner cartridges have a higher initial cost than ink cartridges.
Toner cartridges are physically bigger, meaning they hold more supplies and print more pages. If you do a lot of printing, toner cartridges are more cost-effective.
However, if you don’t print too often, you may find low-output, low-cost ink cartridges more cost-effective.
➜ Related: Inkjet vs Laser Printers
So, Ink or Toner? Which Is Better For You?
High-end commercial inkjet printers are used for product packaging, posters, marketing materials, advertisements and more.
Laser printers and color copiers used to be too big and expensive for home and small business use, but that’s all changed due to compact printer designs and cheaper laser technology.
Now laser printers and inkjet printers are priced nearly the same. It will cost more for new toner cartridges than for new ink cartridges, but, by comparison, you’ll get a much higher page count.
How Do I Know if My Printer Needs Toner vs Ink?
You can check your printer manual for this, but as a general rule, you need toner for laser printers and ink cartridges for inkjet printers.
How Often Do You Have To Replace Ink vs Toner?
Toner usually has a higher page yield which means that you'll need to change it less frequently compared to ink. Plus, as already mentioned above, ink cartridges may expire, dry up, and get clogged if not used enough or in time. This means that sometimes you will need to replace your ink cartridges even if it has not been used for 100%.
Toner cartridges, at the same time, don't dry or expire.