HP 26A vs. HP 26X: Which Toner Cartridge To Choose

Contents:

HP’s 26A and 26X toner cartridges are often compared because they look similar, work in the same printers, and deliver the same print quality.

However, there are important differences that can affect how often you replace toner and how much you spend over time.

Let’s start with what these cartridges have in common before breaking down where they differ.

What HP 26A and HP 26X Have in Common

Both HP 26A (CF226A) and HP 26X (CF226X) are genuine HP black toner cartridges designed for HP LaserJet Pro 400-series printers.

Either cartridge can be installed without modification and will produce the same high-quality results.

In everyday use, both cartridges offer:

  • Sharp, professional-looking text
  • Clean and consistent graphics
  • Reliable performance without smearing or fading
  • Full compatibility with HP printer firmware
  • Safe operation that helps protect your printer

From a print-quality standpoint, there is no advantage to choosing one over the other. The difference lies in how much toner each cartridge contains.

Compatible Printers

Both cartridges are compatible with the following HP LaserJet models:

Where HP 26A and HP 26X Differ

Feature HP 26A (CF226A) HP 26X (CF226X)
Cartridge Type Standard-yield toner High-yield toner
Page Yield (5% coverage) Up to 3,100 pages Up to 9,000 pages
Typical Toner Buzz Price $149 $259
Average Cost Per Page About 5 cents per page About 3 cents per page
Replacement Frequency More frequent replacements Fewer replacements
Best For Light or occasional printing Regular or higher-volume printing

Although HP 26A and HP 26X toner cartridges are identical in terms of print quality and compatibility, they differ in a few practical areas that can significantly affect day-to-day printing and long-term costs.

These differences mainly relate to toner capacity, replacement frequency, and overall value.

Page Yield

The most important difference between HP 26A and HP 26X is page yield. HP 26A is a standard-yield cartridge rated for approximately 3,100 pages, based on the industry standard of 5% page coverage.

HP 26X, on the other hand, is a high-yield cartridge capable of printing up to 9,000 pages under the same conditions. This higher page yield means the HP 26X contains substantially more toner, allowing it to last much longer before needing replacement.

Cost Per Page Comparison

When the cost per page is considered, the difference between the two cartridges becomes clearer.

Cost per page is calculated using the cartridge price and the total number of pages it can print.

At typical Toner Buzz pricing:

  • The HP 26A cartridge costs $149 and prints up to 3,100 pages. The total cost is spread across those pages, resulting in an average printing cost of about 5 cents per page.

  • The HP 26X cartridge costs $259 and prints up to 9,000 pages. Because the cost is spread across a much larger number of pages, the average printing cost drops to about 3 cents per page.

Although the HP 26X has a higher upfront price, its higher page yield results in a lower cost per printed page. This makes it the more economical option for users who print regularly.

Replacement Frequency

Because of its lower page yield, the HP 26A needs to be replaced more often, especially in offices that print regularly. More frequent replacements can interrupt workflow and increase maintenance time.

The HP 26X helps reduce these interruptions because it lasts significantly longer between replacements. For busy offices or shared printers, fewer cartridge changes can make everyday printing more efficient and predictable.

Best Use Case

HP 26A is best suited for users with light printing needs who want to minimize upfront spending. Home offices and small teams that print infrequently may find it sufficient.

HP 26X is designed for higher-volume printing environments where efficiency, reduced downtime, and long-term cost savings are more important than initial purchase price.

Which Cartridge Should You Buy? A Quick Checklist

Choosing between HP 26A and HP 26X becomes easier when you consider how the printer is used on a day-to-day basis.

Reviewing the points below can help clarify which cartridge fits your needs.

  • How often printing takes place during a typical week or month
  • Whether the printer is used by one person or shared by several users
  • How frequently toner replacement is acceptable
  • Preference for lower upfront cost or lower long-term printing cost
  • Importance of minimizing interruptions caused by toner changes

For lighter or occasional printing, HP 26A is usually sufficient.

For more frequent printing and fewer cartridge changes, HP 26X is generally the better choice.

Where To Buy HP 26A and HP 26X

Once you have decided which cartridge fits your needs, purchasing from Toner Buzz helps simplify the process.

Product listings clearly show pricing, page yield, and compatible printer models, making it easier to confirm you are selecting the correct cartridge.

Toner Buzz offers genuine HP 26A and HP 26X toner cartridges, so you receive the same performance and print quality described in this comparison.

Ordering from a single source also makes reordering easier when it is time to replace your toner again.

share your printer experience